Friday, November 30, 2012

why 66 A happened

Whether its television or newspapers or social media or e zines, one encounters Section 66 A of the IT Act in all one's meandering journeys these days. Some commentators have read the said clause,  some haven't, some understand it, some don't, some are genuinely concerned, some are not, but every one is talking about it. We owe a debt of gratitude to K Chidambaram, B Thackeray, and Mumbai Police. Had it not been for these worthy men, each one of us would have remained in blissful ignorance of Section 66 A ----- till dragged to the nearest police station for reason of an offending FB post!

Have we asked ourselves the reason for such ignorance? There are more than 40 Bills which are either pending introduction in the Parliament, or have been introduced and are to be passed. Other than the Lokpal bill, which erupted into national conscience thanks to India Against Corruption, most of us would be hard put to name even 2 or 3 pending Bills. As for the provisions of these Bills, the level of ignorance will be even higher, notwithstanding the fact that when enacted into law, these will directly impact our lives, our rights, responsibilities and privileges.

The media too remains mostly silent ---- neither the national newspapers (with exceptions like The Hindu) nor national TV channels carry any discussion on proposed legislation. All the discussions take place, if at all, post facto.

Is it the case that we are too busy to keep ourselves abreast of developments in at least one or two large areas of public policy? I think not ---- middle class lives are far more comfortable and far less tedious than they were 30 years ago. We have plenty of leisure. What we do with our hours of leisure is, however, dictated by an almost frantic attempt to have "fun"---- lots of television, lots of shopping, lots of eating out, lots of sight seeing in India and abroad, in short, lots of stuff that places no burden on the mind. None of these activities is undesirable per se ----- but the fact that this is what we mostly do in our leisure hours and have totally dissociated ourselves from the making of public policy is disastrous for the nation. The educated middle class owes it to itself and the nation to make an effort to learn, perhaps master, those aspects of public policy that do not require expert knowledge ----- even esoteric subjects like atomic energy have some aspects that a layman could acquaint himself with if he tried. It is only a well informed citizen who can trigger/participate in public debate on issues of public importance. That such public debate can influence policy is something all of us have seen vis a vis the Lokpal bill, which would have remained in hibernation had the ordinary Indian not begun talking about it in every nook and corner of the country.  It is only when each one of us begins to participate in policy making to the best of his ability that more such successes will happen, and there will be an enrichment in the quality of our lives, the future of the nation, and the legacy that we leave behind for the next generation.

There are some excellent online resources to aid one in this effort ---- one is http://www.prsindia.org/,which aims to increase public engagement on issues of national importance. 

Let us not leave the task of nation building to the government -----let each one of us also assume that responsibility.

8 comments:

  1. Thought provoking indeed. It is a must for every individual to be involved. But how? Havent we seen what happened when the civil society mooted the JanLokpal when the successive governments for over 4 decades failed to enact it? Didnt the government, assisted by the 'helping hands' of the media, ridicule them saying that it is the Parliament's prerogative to make laws? So can the author enlighten how the middle class should get involved in a worthless exercise and simply toe the line of dictatorial law making in a democratic country, that encourages graft & greed of leaders and punishes everyone else who stands on the way? That gives clean chits to the thieves and robbers of the country's wealth and punishes a boy who would steal bread to have his first meal in a week?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The fact that Lokpal bill has travelled a greater distance in 1 year than it had in the past 40 years is testimony of the power of people participation.Now, responding to the public debate on Sec 66 A, the govt has issued guidelines that a complaint under 66A will only be looked into be senior police officers. Let us not lose hope ---- optimism is the foundation of courage!
      http://businesstoday.intoday.in/story/govt-modifies-sec-66-of-it-act-facebook-comment-actions/1/190257.html

      Delete
  2. Excellent post. i agree completely. i myself had written something similar some time back about the Lokpal movement: http://blog.free-radical.in/2012/08/anna-hazare-and-indian-middle-class.html.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. very well articulated post, Sidharth ---carry on the good work!

      Delete
  3. It seems 66A is applicable only to Aam Aadmi. If Aam Aadmi wants to be free from 66A then, there is no option left then to become part of political party: "AAP"

    ReplyDelete
  4. The website listed seems to be down. Haven't been able to get on it. Can you check it and update about the same? It would be a good resource for public policy discourse.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Shruti, try the link "Public Polciy" on this blog ---under the heading "Favourites".

    ReplyDelete
  6. Now this is a post after my heart!!! So well-said! 66A happened because of our own lack of care in national policy making! And many more bills that are daily being sent through without real indepth discussion...

    ReplyDelete